Score: 4

"Killer? Not quite."

submission: KILLER ON THE ROAD

date: December 12, 2009

Well, I get that your skills weren't as developed back then, so I'll rate objectively by what I see.
The music made the feelings much more intense in this animation.
Love her hair swooshing when she looks back in her car, that's one really good trick with how she moved her head.
Neat part with the flashbacks as well. Something typical of someone who's about to die, eh?

However, this one was a tad short and not very well developed plot-wise.

Score: 7

"..."

submission: Rapaz

date: December 12, 2009

The first classical track gave me goosebumps, yo.
You chose some beautiful music.
Not sure which track was Ennio Morricone's, though.

I absolutely loved the graphic work with the floating blood drops and the blood flowing against the wind while the boy was still on top of the bird.
Also, the depth of field was great. It was a very realistic feeling.

Great job, X.

Score: 10

"Goddamn beautiful."

submission: Across The Universe

date: December 12, 2009

I can totally see how this is across the universe. Not just because of The Beatles song.
First of all, I wrote down the little graphic tricks I liked along the animation:
- how the roof broke and how he moved through it
- the way he was kind of 'rolling' on his way to the roof
- how the cross built up of blocks
- the x wound growing
- his hair's motion as he stood on the train
- the yellow color as he fell into the water, it's so eerie
- and the blue as the bubbles escape his mouth

Now, the song was absolutely beautiful and fit the animation in every way (although at first I didn't realize it when he sang about sleeping forever). What song is it and by whom?

The symbolic imagery was great, I'm glad Crartonis elaborated on some of it, it's helpful.
To be honest, I did not expect the ending at all, and it was beautiful, and I was taken aback.
I should have found this loooong ago.
Respect.

Score: 10

"Amazing."

submission: Sentimental Mood (Soprano Sax)

date: March 31, 2009

Great. The best of jazz blues I have seen around on NG so far.
Sounds so professional, it must've been quite time-consuming, huh?
Flows perfectly, and the saxophone perfects it unimaginably.

Thanks for making this piece, it's.. great.

Score: 7

"Whaaaaaq."

submission: Paragon

date: March 22, 2009

Now THIS finally shows that NG Audio Portal is worth something. The most professional sound I heard on this website so far. Great job!

Score: 3

"well."

submission: the elefant man

date: March 22, 2009

Nice vocals, but they deserve better background music.